A xenophobic news aggregator calledWestern Voices world News reposted an post from the New York article concerning new York City’s strongest-in-the-nation person Rights Law. In September 2019 the city clearly affirmed the the law protects new Yorkers from gift harassed due to the fact that of your accent, for speaking a language other than English, or native being referred to as an “illegal alien” the end of hate. Western Voices human being News listed only two bits of comment on the report: the xenophobic heading “Trusting your government and getting conquered by aliens are currently one and the same” and also a meme mirroring a bust the Aristotle through a quotation “Tolerance and Apathy room the critical virtues the a dice society.”moment-g.comhas documented and responded come hate teams using points Aristotle actually created in support of hatred, but Sententiae Antiquae and The Athenian Inspector have actually both shown that this quote shows up nowhere in Aristotle’s work: racists, xenophobes, and nationalists just connect Aristotle’s name to that in order to provide intellectual credibility to your hateful politics.

You are watching: Tolerance and apathy are the last virtues of a dying society

Western Voices civilization News’ commentary on NYC’s accuse — miscellaneous Aristotle never ever said

Western world Voices News is the very same site through headlines such together “Anti-white and anti-American bigots space so enchanted v immigration and also diversity the they want much more of it, even if the expense is more crime” and also “Will the brand-new Afro-Chicano Spanish-Speaking bulk give our beautiful white children and also grandchildren the same legal protections, gyeongju preferences, and subsidies the Hispanics and also African-Americans receive today? You recognize the answer. We’ve to be warned about this because that decades.” that the same site that attacked a U.S. Senator because that proposing a invoice that would end limits on employment-based green cards v an short article that attached to Great-Replacement.com, a website moment-g.com has documented for utilizing Roman history to encourage a racist conspiracy theory.

See more: How Many Ounces In A Hamburger Patty ? How Many Ounces Is A Wendys Hamburger Patty

The classicizing logo design from a previous variation of the site

Clearly this website doesn’t aspire to the very same kind that pseudo-academic tone together the racists the moment-g.com often records using references to Greco-Roman classical times to present their pundit clout. However even below we uncover ancient history being offered in this way. Castle republished a tweet indigenous Canadian white conference Stefan Molyneux, who has much more than 400,000 followers, saying that “if diversity is such a strength, you would imagine the at the very least one ancient culture would have actually used it to dominate the world.” lock predicted the “unless something correct is excellent we might one job hear around the fall of Sweden the same method we learned around the fall of the roman inn Empire,” hence repeating the case popular top top xenophobic sites the immigration resulted in Rome’s collapse. They offered to have a logo incorporating thomas Cole’s idealized picture of Greco-Roman architecture, declaring their website to be “A organization of europe Americans United.” that a logo reminiscent the the neo-Nazi web forumStormfront’slogo mirroring the Parthenon v the slogan “Every Month is White background Month.”

The Aristotle meme originates from a now-deplatformed on facebook page dubbed “Smash social Marxism – The Originals,” v “Cultural Marxism” referring to one of racists’ favourite labels for academic work the promotes diversity and inclusion, and “The Originals” signalling the this web page likely noted a endowment trove/cesspool of appropriations the Greco-Roman classical times being used in support of hate. That website wasn’t most likely the very first to attribute this quote to Aristotle, and it definitely wasn’t the last: Aristotle’s quote lives on, a false yet potent symbol of dislike groups’ ongoing attraction to the old past and also the authority they believe it confers top top them.

To prevent generating website traffic for Western Voices world News we have actually linked above to one archived variation of that story. The original deserve to be uncovered here. Due to the fact that moment-g.com published this item WVWN has changed their website design. Their brand-new site starts with a quote that they attribute to Cicero: “Liberty is the freedom of doing.” This is doubly misleading: the full quote that is attributed come Cicero is “Liberty is the freedom of law what is permitted by law,” a much much more narrow maxim. It appears in plenty of dictionaries that Latin quotations together Libertas est potestas faciendi identifier quod iure liceat as a quote native Cicero. Yet that Latin phrase shows up in nobody of Cicero’s works, no one in any type of Latin work that is had in a significant database of Latin messages spanning number of millennia.